| Author |
Thread |
|
DJ Mouse
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
2,687 posts
Joined: Jul, 2001
|
 Posted - 2002/05/27 : 16:04:48
2 things i'd like to clear up.
first of all,if i rip a tune to mp3 format as long as i don't send it out on a p2p program it's legal,right??
second, i'm thinking of doing a mix and the first track i use is an mp3,i have the tune on record but the record's all scratched up so if i was to download it from somewhere and this copy isn't scratched,is this actually legal/acceptable to do?
--------------------------------------------------
"Don't frown when someone annoys you, it uses 42 muscles. Bitch-slap the fu©ker, it only uses 4"
DJ Mouse
Alert moderator 
|
silver
Admin
Japan
12,547 posts
Joined: Feb, 2001
894 hardcore releases
|
Posted - 2002/05/27 : 18:39:49
First: Depends on the terms and conditions of the record track, what country/state you live in. Generally it is excepted otherwise what the hell are tapes, mini discs and hardware MP3 players for?
Second: The copy you download would be a unlicenced version even if it's the exact same track, meaning you are downloading something you are not licenced to own even if it is the same track you did not record it yourself, so you don't actually own it.
----------------------------------
you, me and hardcore forever.
Alert moderator
|
DJ Mouse
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
2,687 posts
Joined: Jul, 2001
|
Posted - 2002/05/28 : 02:47:34
cheers for that,just didn't know exactly what was legal and what wasn't
--------------------------------------------------
"Don't frown when someone annoys you, it uses 42 muscles. Bitch-slap the fu©ker, it only uses 4"
DJ Mouse
Alert moderator
|
strychnine
Advanced Member
Australia
2,268 posts
Joined: Feb, 2002
92 hardcore releases
|
Posted - 2002/05/28 : 23:18:12
so ... basically what ur saying is that it would be best to rip the track as soon as i get the record (while it's still good) or else i'll be forced to act illegally to get a digital copy when it's all scratched and stuff later and i can't find the record anywhere else?
______________________________
Don't dream it's over
Alert moderator
|
DJ Mouse
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
2,687 posts
Joined: Jul, 2001
|
Posted - 2002/05/29 : 07:43:32
that's what i do with all mine,which is why i wanted to know if it was legal or not
--------------------------------------------------
"Don't frown when someone annoys you, it uses 42 muscles. Bitch-slap the fu©ker, it only uses 4"
DJ Mouse
Alert moderator
|
Elysium
Junior Member
Sweden
119 posts
Joined: May, 2002
117 hardcore releases
|
Posted - 2002/05/29 : 12:14:29
There's an additional twist to the case too =)
MP3's doesn't have UNIQUE identifiers, so they can't be traced backwards. So if you download the file (cause your own record is scratched), then it's only illegal when you're downloading it. When it's finished (assuming RIAA didn't trace you) it's a perfectly legal MP3 =)
__________________________________
Friendship, Unity, Caring, Kindness!
Alert moderator
Edited by - Elysium on 2002/05/29 12:15:49 |
DJSuperb
Average Member
United Kingdom
160 posts
Joined: May, 2002
|
Posted - 2002/05/29 : 12:35:54
Its like with the CDs (music and software) you own - you are legally allowed to own a back up copy. Obviously ur not allowed to "share" this copy tho!
12" of Love
__________________________________
www.factoriasonora.co.uk/community
Alert moderator
|
Midway_raver
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
1,032 posts
Joined: Sep, 2001
|
 Posted - 2002/05/29 : 14:56:05
well surely it is liek "roms" if u own teh cart /cd / dvd woteva u r allowed to have a "rom" of this game otherwise u have 2 delete it in 24 hours. Surely if u own teh vinyl and paid ur money 2 teh licensy for teh original u are entitled to own a "back up" mp3 of it and use it in a mix coz u have purchased the vinyl....Well thats what wud b common sense anyway.
Like a bolt of lightning it's so frightning..Get ur brain now we're igniting
__________________________________
You will not laugh, You will not cry, You will learn by the numbers!
Alert moderator
|
silver
Admin
Japan
12,547 posts
Joined: Feb, 2001
894 hardcore releases
|
Posted - 2002/05/29 : 20:34:22
That delete it in 24 hours thing is just crap, it's not legal.
----------------------------------
you, me and hardcore forever.
Alert moderator
|
Brian K
Advanced Member
United States
8,663 posts
Joined: Sep, 2001
528 hardcore releases
|
Posted - 2002/05/29 : 23:03:56
and like people really delete them after 24 hrs anyway =P
"As punishment for your desertion, it's company policy to give you the plague."
__________________________________
"we'll delete the weak"
Alert moderator
|
DJ Mouse
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
2,687 posts
Joined: Jul, 2001
|
Posted - 2002/05/30 : 02:41:23
lol i never do, i got roms on my hard drive at home that are over a year old let alone 24 hours.
and have you noticed they all say "delete from your hard drive after 24 hours", just put them on cd (floppy if they fit coz a lot of them do)
--------------------------------------------------
"Don't frown when someone annoys you, it uses 42 muscles. Bitch-slap the fu©ker, it only uses 4"
DJ Mouse
Alert moderator
|
Midway_raver
Advanced Member
United Kingdom
1,032 posts
Joined: Sep, 2001
|
Posted - 2002/06/01 : 03:41:29
Thats what it says on most download sites........Well i got roms and i dont think teh games companies give a shit about a game from about 1995.....
i think you should be able 2 legally download mp3's of deleted tracks aswell persoanlly.
Like a bolt of lightning it's so frightning..Get ur brain now we're igniting
__________________________________
You will not laugh, You will not cry, You will learn by the numbers!
Alert moderator
|
an mp3 issue,legalities
Printer friendly
